As part of the largest investment in coal-fueled synthetic natural gas plants ever, the central Chinese government recently approved construction of nine large-scale plants capable of producing more than 37 billion cubic meters of synthetic natural gas annually. Private companies are planning to build more than 30 other plants, capable of producing as much as 200 million cubic meters of natural gas each year—far exceeding China’s current natural gas demand.

These plants are coming online at a rapid pace. If all nine plants planned by the Chinese government were built, they would emit 21 billion tons of carbon dioxide over a typical 40-year lifetime, seven times the greenhouse gas that would be emitted by traditional natural gas plants. If all 40 of the facilities are built, their carbon dioxide emissions would be an astonishing 110 billion tons. [They] will lock in high greenhouse gas emissions, water use and mercury pollution for decades.

—Robert B. Jackson

The analysis by Chi-Jen Yang, a research scientist at Duke’s Center on Global Change (lead author) and Robert B. Jackson, Nicholas Professor of Environmental Sciences and director of the Duke Center on Global Change finds that:

• If the gas produced by the new plants is used to generate electricity, the total lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions would be 36% to 82% higher than pulverized coal-fired power.

• If the synthetic natural gas made by the plants were used to fuel vehicles, the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions would be twice as large as from gasoline-fueled vehicles.

The study notes that the plants would also emit hydrogen sulfide and mercury, which, if not properly scrubbed and treated, are potentially harmful to human health.

These environmental costs have been largely neglected in the drive to meet the nation’s growing energy needs, the researchers say, and might lock China on an irreversible and unsustainable path for decades to come.

Excessive water consumption by the plants is also a concern, the researchers noted. Producing synthetic natural gas requires 50 to 100 times the amount of water you need to produce shale gas, Yang said. The nine plants approved by the government—most of which are located in desert or semi-desert regions in Xinjiang and Inner Mongolia—will consume more than 200 million tons of water annually and could worsen water shortages in areas that already are under significant water stress, he added.

At a minimum, Chinese policymakers should delay implementing their synthetic natural gas plan to avoid a potentially costly and environmentally damaging outcome. An even better decision would be to cancel the program entirely.

The increased carbon dioxide emissions from the nine government-approved plants alone will more than cancel out all of the reductions in greenhouse gas emissions from China’s recent investments in wind and solar electricity. While we applaud China’s rapid development in clean energy, we must be cautious about this simultaneous high-carbon leapfrogging.

—Chi-Jen Yang

Resources

• Chi-Jen Yang, Robert B. Jackson (2013) “China’s Synthetic Natural Gas Revolution,” Nature Climate Change doi: 10.1038/nclimate1988